Natalie Butler-Megerson

Hi, I’m Natalie! I would love to show you around my hometown of San Marcos and share how it’s grown and changed over the years. When it comes to making real estate decisions—whether it’s a homestead or an investment property—I believe it’s crucial to understand the big picture.

As a lifelong San Marcos resident with family roots stretching back six generations, I have a deep connection to this community. I grew up right here, graduated from San Marcos Academy, and later earned my BA in Advertising from Texas State University.

I’ve been honored to achieve Elite status with REAL Brokerage as an individual agent in 2022, 2023, and 2025. Our team, The Local Choice Group – REAL Broker, has also been recognized as one of the Top Teams in Texas (2022 & 2024) and was voted Best of Hays 2024 Real Estate Agency. Personally, I was awarded Best of Hays 2024 Realtor and nominated among the top 3 Realtors in the two years prior.

I live in San Marcos with my husband, our four children, and our many pets. Outside of real estate, I’m passionate about foster care, adoption, and animal advocacy.

At the Local Choice Group, our goal is to provide exceptional service to our past, present, and future clients. We want to be your “go-to” team for San Marcos and the surrounding Hill Country. I would love the opportunity to earn your business, listen to your story, and help you find the perfect place to begin your next chapter.